Dr Felicity Gerry QC Secures Acquittal on ‘Joint Enterprise Murder’

Felicity’s young adult client was acquitted of murder and attempted murder at Bradford Crown Court on Thursday 14th July 2022. The prosecution had alleged that there was a joint plan to exact revenge after an attack upon her client’s friend. The jury convicted three in the group, one as principal in murder and wounding with intent and the others as secondary parties in manslaughter. It was accepted by the prosecution and obvious from the CCTV footage that her client had no weapon and chased nobody. However, the judicial directions set out the prosecution case based on an inference that he jumped out of a car and stood in the road so that relevant people knew he was there and by doing so, his actions encouraged and were intended to encourage the principal offender to carry out his attacks. Plainly by the verdicts, the jury rejected the prosecution case theory that Felicity’s client was part of a plan to attack and they must also have concluded that he did not encourage any such conduct at the scene. This is a case that demonstrates the value of precision on how a case is put and the effort that needs to be exerted to properly reach not guilty verdicts. You can read more about the case here, but it is important to note the sentencing remarks do not reflect Felicity’s client’s case: https://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/news/20282656.kian-tordoff-murder-trial-every-word-judges-sentencing-speech-full/. We also ask you to bear in mind there have been some dreadful racist comments in relation to this matter on social media. Felicity takes the issue of race in the criminal justice system very seriously. You can read her article on race and joint enterprise. Felicity led Sanjeev Sharma of Equity Chambers and was instructed by Ali and Co Solicitors in Bradford.

Striking Barristers – Our open letter to the Times

Sir, The lord chief justice has issued a warning shot to the Criminal Bar by raising the prospect of severe disciplinary sanctions against any barrister who strikes (“Top judge wants striking barristers to face misconduct charges”, Jun 23). Although he says in his latest memo sent to all judges that “the judiciary is not a party to the dispute”,which is set to escalate to court walkouts next week, he has instructed them to report the names of any barrister who takes such action. The guidance is being read by many of us who prosecute and defend as an attempt to intimidate us. We are concerned that the independent office of the lord chief justice risks being seen as doing the job of a partisan enforcer for a government whose degrading of the justice system has been draining it of the very professionals on which it relies: barristers to prosecute, defend and provide judges. Our action is about protecting these professionals, and the lord chief justice clearly cares about them, but his warning may have the effect of condemning the courts to a painful asphyxiation rather than providing the oxygen that we all, judges, barristers and those unwillingly caught up in the system, so urgently need. Times Letter: https://www.thetimes.co.uk/ Caroline Goodwin QC also appeared on Time Radio with Henry Bonsu/ Caroline Goodwin QC, Trinity Chambers, former chair of the Criminal Bar Association (CBA); Chris Henley QC, Mountford Chambers, former chair CBA; Mark Whitehall, Colleton Chambers; Emily Pitts, Colleton Chambers, Andrew Wilkins, Cornwall Street Chambers, Oliver Woolhouse, Cornwall Street Chambers; Roderick Johnson QC, Goldsmith Chambers; Anthony Metzer QC, Goldsmith Chambers; Gordon Cole QC, Goldsmith Chambers; Barry Grennan, Kenworthy’s Chambers; Jonathan Laidlaw QC, 2 Hare Court; Christopher Coltart QC, 2 Hare Court; Ieuan Rees, Angel Chambers; Andrew O’Byrne QC, St John’s Buildings; Ella Embleton, Broadway House Chambers; David McGonigal, Broadway House Chambers; Nicola Hoskins, Broadway House Chambers; Peter Joyce QC, 1 High Pavement; David Brooke QC, KBW Chambers; Nicholas Campbell QC, KBW Chambers; Keir Monteith QC; Garden Court Chambers; David Emanuel QC, Garden Court Chambers, Rajiv Menon QC; Garden Court Chambers; Anya Lewis QC, Garden Court Chambers; Henry Blaxland QC, Garden Court Chambers; Mark George QC, Garden Court North; Mark Kimsey, Castle Chambers; Simon Eckersley, Castle Chambers; Julia King, Castle Chambers; Susan Meek, Rose Court Chambers; Mark Fraser, Rose Court Chambers; Allison Hunter QC, 23 Essex Street; Paul Bogan QC, 23 Essex Street; Christian Moll, Blackfriars Chambers; Jonathan Mole, 9 King’s Bench Walk; Shabeena Azhar, 9 King’s Bench Walk; Martin Rutherford QC, 15NBS Chambers; Tana Adkin QC, 15NBS Chambers; Gavin Holme, 4 King’s Bench Walk; Simon Csoka QC, Libertas Chambers; Siobhan Grey QC, Libertas Chambers; Adam Kane QC, Libertas Chambers; John Morgans, Octogon Chambers; Ben Knight, Central Chambers; Tony Shaw QC, Red Lion Chambers; Kate Bex QC, Red Lion Chambers; Reil-Karmy Jones QC, Red Lion Chambers; Christopher Paxton QC, Red Lion Chambers; Adam Wiseman QC, Red Lion Chambers; Jane Bewesey QC, Red Lion Chambers; Michelle Nelson QC, Red Lion Chambers; Simon Spence QC , Red Lion Chambers; Steven Kay QC, Head 9BR Chambers; Abbas Lakha QC, 9BR Chambers; Elizabeth Marsh QC, 9BR Chambers; Peter Glenser QC, 9BR Chambers; Justin Rouse QC, 9BR Chambers; Karim Khalil QC, Drystone Chambers; Michael Magarian QC, Drystone Chambers; Toby Hedworth QC, Trinity Chambers; Michael Holland, Furnival Chambers; Sally O’Neill QC, Furnival Chambers, Former Chair of the Criminal Bar Association; Mark Rhind QC, Exchange Chambers; Scott Brady, 3TG; John Femi-Ola QC, 3TG; Adam Davis QC, 3TG; Jeremy Wainwright QC; Timothy Hannam QC, Citadel Chambers; Katherine Goddard QC, Bank House Chambers; Mark Rainsford QC, 33  Chancery Lane